Germany is on the brink of a new era in leadership, with Friedrich Merz and the Christian Democratic Union (CDU) set to lead the country after a decisive election victory. However, one of the key questions facing Germany and Europe is how the new government will navigate relations with U.S. President Donald Trump. Merz, who has a long history of advocating for strong transatlantic ties, has signaled a shift in Germany’s approach, emphasizing European independence from the U.S. How will this impact U.S.-German relations, and what does it mean for Europe’s geopolitical future?
Merz’s Vision for a Stronger Europe
Following his party’s election win, Merz emphasized his commitment to strengthening European unity. He stated that Germany must work towards a more independent and self-sufficient Europe. This marks a departure from the CDU’s historical stance, which has traditionally favored close relations with the United States.
Merz’s comments have raised eyebrows among political analysts. Evelyn Gaiser, a policy advisor at the Konrad Adenauer Foundation, noted that past CDU leaders, including Konrad Adenauer and Helmut Kohl, played crucial roles in deepening U.S.-German ties. Merz, however, seems poised to redefine Germany’s role in the transatlantic alliance.
A Longstanding Transatlanticist with Changing Priorities
Despite his recent statements, Merz has historically been a strong advocate for transatlantic relations. From 2009 to 2019, he chaired the Atlantik-Brücke (Atlantic Bridge), an organization dedicated to fostering U.S.-German cooperation. He has also expressed admiration for former U.S. President Ronald Reagan and has visited the United States over 100 times.
However, his relationship with Trump’s administration appears strained. Trump’s skepticism towards NATO and his push for European nations to increase their own defense spending have led Merz to reassess Germany’s reliance on the U.S. The shift is evident in his remarks following U.S. Vice President JD Vance’s controversial speech at the Munich Security Conference, where Vance suggested Europe’s biggest threats were internal rather than external. Merz responded by calling it a “wake-up call” for Europe to reinforce its own security framework.
Trump and Merz: Points of Agreement and Division
Despite their differences on foreign policy, Merz and Trump share similarities in domestic policy. Both leaders advocate for pro-business policies, reduced regulations, and stricter immigration controls. Merz’s firm stance on migration played a significant role in his election victory, appealing to voters concerned about border security. His approach has drawn comparisons to Trump’s own hardline immigration policies, including his push to continue building a wall along the U.S.-Mexico border.
When it comes to cultural and social issues, Merz and Trump also align. Merz has expressed conservative views on gender and family issues, mirroring Trump’s traditionalist rhetoric. However, their foreign policy priorities sharply diverge. While Trump has distanced the U.S. from European security affairs and has shown a willingness to engage with Russia, Merz has been vocal about maintaining Germany’s support for Ukraine and strengthening NATO.
Germany’s Response to Trump’s Foreign Policy
One of the biggest concerns in Europe is Trump’s unpredictable stance on NATO and U.S. commitments to European security. Trump has repeatedly suggested that the U.S. might not defend NATO allies who fail to meet their defense spending obligations. This uncertainty has fueled European leaders’ determination to strengthen regional security cooperation.
Merz has already taken steps to reaffirm Germany’s commitment to Ukraine and European defense. He met with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy in Kyiv in December 2024, underscoring his support for Ukraine in the face of Russian aggression. Merz has also expressed concerns about Trump’s willingness to negotiate directly with Russia, warning that any deal made without European input would be unacceptable.
Can Merz Lead Europe in a Post-U.S. Era?
As Germany prepares to form a new government, Merz faces the challenge of uniting Europe in response to a shifting U.S. foreign policy stance. Analysts predict that under his leadership, Germany will push for greater European cooperation on defense, economy, and foreign affairs to counterbalance the uncertainty surrounding U.S. commitments.
Evelyn Gaiser believes a CDU-led government will seek to position Europe as a stronger global player. “Merz’s primary objective will be to enhance Europe’s independence while reinforcing its economic and geopolitical influence,” she said. Rachel Tausendfreund of the German Council on Foreign Relations (DGAP) echoed this sentiment, noting that Merz will likely prioritize European security cooperation to reduce reliance on the U.S.
However, there are lingering questions about Merz’s ability to navigate this complex geopolitical landscape. Unlike his predecessors, he has never held a top executive position at the national or regional level. His ability to lead Europe through this transition will be tested in the coming months.
Germany’s relationship with the U.S. is entering a new chapter under Friedrich Merz. While he shares some ideological similarities with Donald Trump, their foreign policy priorities diverge significantly. As Trump pushes for Europe to take on more responsibility for its own security, Merz is positioning Germany as a key player in strengthening European unity and independence.
The coming years will determine whether Germany can successfully navigate this shift while maintaining strong ties with the U.S. and its European allies. One thing is certain: the transatlantic relationship will not be the same as it was before.
For more updates on this developing story, visit Issue N Fact.
